Wednesday, February 19, 2014

Rhetorical Exploration 2- Sherlock

BBC's Sherlock is a contemporary adaptation of the original Sherlock Holmes stories. Being a modern version, Sherlock utilizes many forms of technology to help solve his cases. Staying true to his origins however, Sherlock's greatest asset is logic. In a wonderful example of the Socratic Method, he takes a situation and by analyzing all of the facts presented, deduces a single truth to solve the crime; what he refers to as "The Science of Deduction." Due to his rapid, logical intake of information and lack of people skills (he refers to himself as a "high functioning sociopath"), Sherlock is often referred to as a "freak" by some of the detectives that are not very fond of him. This is very reminiscent of how Socrates was viewed for his love of logic and reason.

The show does a fantastic job using visual rhetoric. They literally show the words running through Sherlock's mind as he analyzes the crime scene showing his mental process. Above is a YouTube compilation of scenes where Sherlock analyzes crime scenes and people. Entering the crime scene, we would have no idea where to begin looking for clues and might not even realize they were clues had we found them. However, after watching Sherlock use logic to pick apart the scene, the clues become extremely obvious in hindsight. We think, "Why didn't I notice that?!?"

The character of John Watson symbolizes the viewer and how we are outsiders to Sherlock's effortless use of logic. Seeing this quick deduction can be quite unsettling to watch because it illustrates just how little we actually see in our everyday life.We realize that we don't use logic enough to truly think things out in our day to day lives. We accept the surface explanation of what we are presented with and usually don't bother to look beyond a simple meaning. Perhaps if we begin to look beyond what we see, we too could become masters at the Science of Deduction and impress/terrify people with our super weird observational skills.







No comments:

Post a Comment